Medication and Tom Cruz
I might as well jump into the fray about the contention between Scientology and Psychiatry. Last week Tom Cruz went on the Today show to promote his movie The War of the Worlds and got into an argument with Matt Lauer about the use of psychotropic medications. Lots of news stations covered the argument. I saw it rebroadcast on CNN. I then saw a panel discussion on the Today show the next day with the strangest collection of “experts” about medication. These included a psychiatrist who is opposed to psychotropic medication, a psychologist, and Marie Osmond who had suffered from post partum depression. I’m not sure what anyone could reasonably get out of those “experts.”
There’s a long history of several hundred years of problems with psychiatry. Psychiatrists were making guesses at what was working and what wasn’t for very serious mental illness. These were the people who were confined in insane asylums. These were people with illnesses like dementia, serious organic disorders, the criminally insane, schizophrenia, and bipolar disorder. Occasionally a major depression would slip in, but that was rare. The big break through happened when someone noticed that some schizophrenics with high blood pressure got better on a blood pressure medication known as reserpine. (Schizophrenics see things, and hear things and have delusions and strange thinking, they don’t have split personalities.) So some researchers started looking at why people got better on reserpine and made the hypothesis that chemicals in the brain caused people to be psychotic. So a whole variety of chemicals were developed by drug companies to try to normalize these abnormal brains. If you take pictures of schizophrenics brains on MRI they look different than people with normal brains. They also look different on autopsy. The same is true with dementia also known as Alzheimer’s disease where the entire cortex of the brain shrinks. This starts after age 45 and no one knows why it happens in some people. It produces memory loss. Memory loss isn’t the only symptom but it’s the most obvious. Bipolar disorder used to be known as manic depressive illness. The name was changed a few years ago but the disease is the same. There are periods of grandiosity and severe sleep disturbance and possible delusions with a frank manic episode, and periods of depression. Every single one of these conditions can be improved with medication. In many cases, medication takes these people from institutional care to functional ability. If it is possible for any of these people to live independently without medication outside of an institution then they should absolutely make an attempt at that prior to attempting medication.
Medication is used as a last resort. Hospitalization is used as a last resort. Institutional care on a permanent basis is used when all methods of treatment fail and the person can not live safely in society. Right now people get psychiatrically hospitalized because they are either dangerous to themselves, dangerous to others or gravely disabled and not able to adequately care for themselves. Medications are used on an urgent basis to prevent hospitalization. With correct supervision sometimes they work and are life saving. Sometimes they are given out like candy with little supervision and little direction. They can be harmful when used in that fashion.
Medications are also used because they are faster. They can be problematic when used like this. A child is bouncing off the walls at home. The child isn’t sleeping at all for days on end. The family is staying awake in shifts to watch the child to try to prevent the child from injuring himself. They have relatives coming in to help. There is a family history of bipolar disorder. There are clear parenting issues. The child is getting injured and has been breaking things in the home and climbing on things like bookcases and pulling them over on himself. The kid is running the home. He’s not socialized, is becoming hyperactive, inattentive, isn’t listening, and is getting aggressive. He’s been kicked out of preschool. The place to start with this isn’t medication, but I see lots of these kids coming in for evaluation on very strong medications, some not even approved for use in children. This is a poor practice and is simply done to be faster. Medication alone won’t solve all the problems and may create new ones. Medication may not even be indicated.
In contrast is the case where a teen is showing some episodes of brief delusions. Occasionally he reports everyone is against him. Sometimes he thinks things have been crawling on him. It’s only happened a couple of times so it’s not a big deal and no one is prescribing any medication. He’s being monitored closely. There’s a family history of schizophrenia. There’s been a suicide and a homicide in the family so the stakes are high here. The family is working closely on parenting issues. He’s had normal teen conflicts. Every once in awhile something seems to go awry. The thinking process is disordered. So far he doesn’t need any medication. He functions at home, with peers and at school with just some unusual episodes. The family members all understand the stakes. He can stay the way he is and be a productive member of society. He may not need medication. With stress he may become paranoid and delusional but not need medication. Some members of the family have been able to do that. Others have gone on to develop the full paranoid schizophrenic syndrome and have not been functional even with medication requiring episodes of hospitalization or institutional care. Others have decided to discontinue medication after being released from institutions or hospitals and have either killed someone or killed themselves while in a delusional state.
Now I talk to people who aren’t taking medication, or who are struggling with violence frequently. I think that before someone decides that taking medication is so appalling as Tom Cruz suggests, that they need to recognize that for some the alternative is suicide, homicide–with the attendant prison term, or a life in unspeakable torment by internal demons rendering them unable to function in society.
I don’t think medication is a choice to be made in a flip or glib manner. I don’t think it’s to be made on the basis of what’s easier. I do think it should be the last option. I certainly wish the drug manufactures would test medications on children so we knew the effects. I wish parents were advised when drugs for their children were being provided off-label so they could have informed consent that we don’t have a clue what the medications are doing to their children. But I think psychiatric medications allow people to live full and productive lives outside of State run institutions. Psychotropic medications have saved lives.
